|シアワセナオススメ - HAPPY RECOMMENDERS -|

Lay off the cssawards.com and add

投稿者: Mariann Slothower | 2012年06月02日 14:07

This charter is an excellent start. But I would like to see a Guideline Zero that lays out what the purposes (plural) of peer-review are. I see three very distinct purposes, and much of the frustration with peer-review comes from reviews that blur these.1. Assessing whether the paper is sound, i.e. does it express a coherent argument that is backed up by data?2. Assessing “importance” or “impact”, i.e. is the paper likely to be seen as a significant advance in its field, and to gather many citations?3. Helping the author improve the paper by constructively suggesting changes that can be made without altering the fundamental nature of the paper.All of these are important contributions, but they are quite separate and should be kept so. In category 3, for example, if a reviewer suggests that a sentence would be easier to parse if changed around, that should certainly not affect the gatekeeping decisions in categories 1 and 2.PLoS ONE has shown the importance of separating caterories 1 and 2. In that journal, and those that now emulate it, the “impact” criterion is explicitly ignored, and all good papers are published however important or unimportant they are considered to be. (This means, among other things, that replication studies are welcome.)This inclusive strategy is not appropriate for all journals — I understand that eLife is actively aiming to reject most submissions on “impact” criteria, in the hope of attaining prestige similar to that of Science and Nature. But even in journals that evaluate for impact, it’s important to separate the two assessment criteria. One important practical implication of this separation is that a subsequent high-volume “eLife ONE” journal could publish all eLife submissions that passed criterion 1 but failed criterion 2 without the need for further review.

投稿者: canada car insurance companies | 2013年09月28日 18:57

Im an actor from the Capilano Musical Theatre program. I just now came across your site and while I commend you on your effort to inform the public on the musicals in Vancouver, you sir have missed several shows.The Threepenny Opera: A rarely done musical but stunning production design and standout performers Exit 22 at Capilano UniversityBye Bye Birdie. Also fantastic production designs as well as a fun and talented actors at Studio 58 at Langara CollegeReefer Madness, by a small local company. Small yet packed with talent , at the PAL theatre I see nothing on here.Flower Drum Song, an older, dated but gem of musical theatre history by Rodgers and Hammerstein produced by Vancouver Asian Canadian Theatre which ran for 3 weeks in may/juneTitanic: musical in concert by Applause. A beautiful and haunting show that had a short 4 day run in may. NothingMaybe its time you had a few more people working with you to ensure you actually cover everything in Vancouver. I suggest getting in contact with the Ovation Award committee which I also sit on, local awards for the musical theatre companies. Please contact me and I will gladly get you a ticket for reviewing the evening.

投稿者: prednisone sale | 2013年10月14日 20:18

Im an actor from the Capilano Musical Theatre program. I just now came across your site and while I commend you on your effort to inform the public on the musicals in Vancouver, you sir have missed several shows.The Threepenny Opera: A rarely done musical but stunning production design and standout performers Exit 22 at Capilano UniversityBye Bye Birdie. Also fantastic production designs as well as a fun and talented actors at Studio 58 at Langara CollegeReefer Madness, by a small local company. Small yet packed with talent , at the PAL theatre I see nothing on here.Flower Drum Song, an older, dated but gem of musical theatre history by Rodgers and Hammerstein produced by Vancouver Asian Canadian Theatre which ran for 3 weeks in may/juneTitanic: musical in concert by Applause. A beautiful and haunting show that had a short 4 day run in may. NothingMaybe its time you had a few more people working with you to ensure you actually cover everything in Vancouver. I suggest getting in contact with the Ovation Award committee which I also sit on, local awards for the musical theatre companies. Please contact me and I will gladly get you a ticket for reviewing the evening.

投稿者: prednisone sale | 2013年10月14日 20:18

I have seen a great deal of useful potins on your site about pcs. However, I've the impression that laptops are still less than powerful more than enough to be a good choice if you frequently do projects that require loads of power, for example video modifying. But for web surfing, word processing, and many other popular computer functions they are all right, provided you cannot mind your little friend screen size. Thank you sharing your ideas.

投稿者: Valeria | 2013年10月19日 12:35

ஹி...ஹி இப்படி சொல்றது எல்லாம் ஏன் தெரியுமா, அவாளே எல்லாம் புடிச்சுக்கிட்டான்னு அடுத்தவங்க சொல்வதற்கு முன் அவங்களே கிளப்பிவிட்டுக்க தான்.இந்திய கிரிக்கெட் அணியில் 11 பேர் ஆடினால் அதில் 8-9 பேர் அவாள் தான்.ஜூனியர் டீம்க்கு ஆள் எடுக்கும் போது தோள்ப்பட்டையை தடவிப்பார்ப்பாங்களாம் உள்ள கயிறு இருக்கான்னு பார்க்க.

投稿者: classes online horse | 2013年10月24日 09:17

Yup, that'll do it. You have my appreciation.

投稿者: insurance quotes auto | 2013年11月01日 21:12

You can always tell an expert! Thanks for contributing.

投稿者: top rated car insurance | 2013年11月02日 23:40

I'm not quite sure how to say this; you made it extremely easy for me!

投稿者: life insurance company in florida | 2013年11月04日 23:02

I'm not quite sure how to say this; you made it extremely easy for me!

投稿者: life insurance company in florida | 2013年11月04日 23:02

That's a quick-witted answer to a difficult question

投稿者: auto insurance quote | 2013年11月06日 12:57

Well put, sir, well put. I'll certainly make note of that.

投稿者: online car insurance quotation | 2013年11月06日 20:55

At last! Someone with the insight to solve the problem!

投稿者: cheap insurance | 2013年11月08日 15:26

At last! Someone with the insight to solve the problem!

投稿者: cheap insurance | 2013年11月08日 15:27

At last! Someone with the insight to solve the problem!

投稿者: cheap insurance | 2013年11月08日 15:27

Ah yes, nicely put, everyone.

投稿者: get car insurance quotes | 2013年11月11日 17:39

That's a creative answer to a difficult question

投稿者: cheap auto insurance Burlington | 2013年11月12日 02:02

That's a creative answer to a difficult question

投稿者: cheap auto insurance Burlington | 2013年11月12日 02:03

That's a creative answer to a difficult question

投稿者: cheap auto insurance Burlington | 2013年11月12日 02:03

The honesty of your posting shines through

投稿者: insurance auto | 2013年11月13日 19:22

That takes us up to the next level. Great posting.

投稿者: car insurance free quotes | 2013年11月14日 12:06

That takes us up to the next level. Great posting.

投稿者: car insurance free quotes | 2013年11月14日 12:07

This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for writing!

投稿者: online casino | 2013年11月15日 07:12

This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for writing!

投稿者: online casino | 2013年11月15日 07:12

Well macadamia nuts, how about that.

投稿者: slot online games | 2013年11月16日 14:18

Well macadamia nuts, how about that.

投稿者: slot online games | 2013年11月16日 14:18

Well macadamia nuts, how about that.

投稿者: slot online games | 2013年11月16日 14:19

What a joy to find such clear thinking. Thanks for posting!

投稿者: buy cheap sildenafil | 2013年11月19日 12:31

What a joy to find such clear thinking. Thanks for posting!

投稿者: buy cheap sildenafil | 2013年11月19日 12:31

For the love of God, keep writing these articles.

投稿者: low cost life insurance | 2013年11月20日 19:43

Great insight. Relieved I\'m on the same side as you.

投稿者: online sildenafil | 2013年11月21日 21:37

Great insight. Relieved I\'m on the same side as you.

投稿者: online sildenafil | 2013年11月21日 21:37

Created the greatest articles, you have.

投稿者: cheapest auto insurance in PA | 2013年11月22日 07:45

This is an article that makes you think "never thought of that!"

投稿者: cheap car insurance | 2013年11月23日 19:10

Always the best content from these prodigious writers.

投稿者: free nj car insurance quotes | 2013年11月24日 02:18

There's a terrific amount of knowledge in this article!

投稿者: viagra online without prescription mastercard | 2013年11月25日 01:10

There's a terrific amount of knowledge in this article!

投稿者: viagra online without prescription mastercard | 2013年11月25日 01:10

There's a terrific amount of knowledge in this article!

投稿者: viagra online without prescription mastercard | 2013年11月25日 01:11

Frankly I think that's absolutely good stuff.

投稿者: auto insurance company commercial | 2013年11月26日 02:06

That's the best answer by far! Thanks for contributing.

投稿者: car coverage insurance in | 2013年11月26日 10:08

I thought I'd have to read a book for a discovery like this!

投稿者: car insurance | 2013年11月27日 09:50

Articles like this just make me want to visit your website even more.

投稿者: insurance health emergency | 2013年11月28日 13:47

It's always a pleasure to hear from someone with expertise.

投稿者: buying priligy online | 2013年12月03日 23:10

That's a crackerjack answer to an interesting question

投稿者: education degree online master | 2013年12月04日 18:43

Kudos to you! I hadn't thought of that!

投稿者: priligy | 2013年12月05日 00:44

That's the perfect insight in a thread like this.

投稿者: cheapest auto insurance rates | 2013年12月06日 09:15

That's the perfect insight in a thread like this.

投稿者: cheapest auto insurance rates | 2013年12月06日 09:15

Kudos! What a neat way of thinking about it.

投稿者: hypnotherapy impotence | 2013年12月07日 13:54

Kudos! What a neat way of thinking about it.

投稿者: hypnotherapy impotence | 2013年12月07日 13:54

Just do me a favor and keep writing such trenchant analyses, OK?

投稿者: buy car insurance online | 2013年12月08日 08:06

Just do me a favor and keep writing such trenchant analyses, OK?

投稿者: buy car insurance online | 2013年12月08日 08:07

Just do me a favor and keep writing such trenchant analyses, OK?

投稿者: buy car insurance online | 2013年12月08日 08:07

All of my questions settled-thanks!

投稿者: inexspensive auto insurance | 2013年12月08日 16:36

Thanks for being on point and on target!

投稿者: low car insurance quotes nj | 2013年12月09日 11:50

I had no idea how to approach this before-now I'm locked and loaded.

投稿者: Cheap Car Insurance Quote | 2013年12月10日 09:18

I had no idea how to approach this before-now I'm locked and loaded.

投稿者: Cheap Car Insurance Quote | 2013年12月10日 09:18

You get a lot of respect from me for writing these helpful articles.

投稿者: cheap car insurance | 2013年12月10日 13:50

My problem was a wall until I read this, then I smashed it.

投稿者: auto insurance quotes | 2013年12月11日 02:24

My problem was a wall until I read this, then I smashed it.

投稿者: auto insurance quotes | 2013年12月11日 02:25

My problem was a wall until I read this, then I smashed it.

投稿者: auto insurance quotes | 2013年12月11日 02:25

Hey, you're the goto expert. Thanks for hanging out here.

投稿者: local cialis online sale | 2013年12月12日 09:14

Fell out of bed feeling down. This has brightened my day!

投稿者: available free slots | 2013年12月14日 10:05

Yeah, that's the ticket, sir or ma'am

投稿者: contents insurance cheaper | 2013年12月15日 03:34

I really couldn't ask for more from this article.

投稿者: insurance young people car | 2013年12月15日 21:30

コメント (64)

コメントを投稿

HAPPY RECOMMENDERS

最近の投稿

最近のコメント

アーカイブ

検索